Parti Gerakan logo

Penang govt faces expenses scandal

11 Jun 2009, 11:00 AM
Posted in

NIBONG TEBAL: The DAP-led Penang state government could be in for another scandal involving one of its assemblymen.

Jawi assemblyman Tan Beng Huat has been accused of misappropriating funds in the form of sponsorship of a local charity organisation.

The matter has since been reported to the Malaysian Anti Corruption Commission (MACC).

This was brought to light by the DAP Nibong Tebal division, which also accused the state party leaders of keeping mum about the matter despite being informed about it.

Division chief Teh Hock Yong yesterday accused Tan of misappropriating RM2,000 in sponsorship of a local charity organisation.

“I have decided to call for a press conference to expose the allegation after Tan and the state DAP leadership failed to publicly deny the allegation since the issue emerged two months ago.”

Teh said he was approached by a Chin Chee Kok Charity Association committee member in April claiming that they had applied for a RM2,000 grant from Tan to purchase a television set and a compact disc player.

He said Tan approved their application and the electrical items were subsequently delivered to the association.

However, it was later discovered that the goods were worth only RM450 and not RM2,000 as promised.

Teh said it was later discovered that Tan had submitted a claim for RM2,000 to a state government agency for the donation.

Teh said he alerted the MACC on April 17 and also informed state government leaders including Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng and state DAP chairman Chow Kon Yeow.

He claimed that instead of getting a swift response, he was shocked when the party leaders advised him not to meddle in the matter since Tan is a DAP assemblyman.

“They even reminded me that there was no need to blow up the issue as the state government had just come to power.

“They said the time was not right to push for a by-election.”

Teh said he was particularly disappointed with Lim’s lukewarm response to the issue despite championing the Competency, Accountability and Transparency policy in running the state government.

He said he would expose more wrongdoings by Tan next month if the assemblyman and state leaders failed to act on the matter.

“We used to be bashing Barisan Nasional representatives for such matters and I would be a useless DAP member if I just sit on this issue pretending that nothing has happened.”

by NST Online » Local News
http://www.nst.com.my

37 comments, add yours

1 Xiao Ah Mao 11 Jun 2009, 9:31 PM

This clearly indicates that the so called and highly publicized CAT policy of the present Penang Government is just an EMPTY SLOGAN !

2 Xhu Chen 12 Jun 2009, 4:32 PM

Dear Gerakan editor team,

PKR already making changes to their party.

For example, they are going to reduce the age limit for youth from 40 to 35 years old.
Gerakan Youth age limit is still 45 years old. So, why are there so many old people allowed in gerakan youth? Is it just to hold on power by some overage youth?

Second thing, there is going to be direct voting by PKR to elect their president. Is gerakan still going to take the old delegate voting system?

Just my thought that before Gerakan want to criticise others, they must first make changes and improve themself first la! Talk is cheap!

3 Soon Kok Wah 13 Jun 2009, 10:17 AM

Morning Xhu Chen, you may miss reading the topic of ” Penang government faces expenses scandal”. I understand your feeling, as it may bring the good changes to GERAKAN. Please allow me to suggest that, just let GERAKAN members to critics The DAP, PKR and PAS, as we are opposition party in Penang.

Who ever lead the state government from now, need to review the system of distribute funding to the residents and organisation. We need to set up an organisation / system to monitor these kind of fund distribution as it involve huge of money (POTENTIAL CORRUPTION). All ADUNS need to C.C. the copy of “fund approving letter” to that monitoring organisation. I know many residents believed that the ADUN did not involve in this issue of corruption, however, he should be blamed as he did not follow up until the end with the funding approve by him.


Regards
Soon Kok Wah

4 penangites 13 Jun 2009, 3:40 PM

I personally very agree if Jawi assemblyman Tan Beng Huat confirm found guity by MACC and resign for responsible.

I realise that this is a news copy from NST (UMNO control press) and not from Gerakan columnist. I urge gerakan columnist & editor don’t be so lazy to publish your own statement/blog/column. After all this blog was form for the purpose for gerakan to reach their members and support, not use as another UMNO propaganda like Utusan and NST.

(wake up gerakan!! UMNO hv slap you on the face and you still licking their boot). Dont let rakyat think this gerakan blog is another UMNO control media.

Rakyat see Gerakan as useless party, licking UMNO ass for the sake of the position in cabinet and kan tau.

IF Mr.Tan confirm guilty, compare to those corrupted UMNO ADUN, he is nothing, not even near。When UMNO ADUN hv corruption case (eg million dollors land scam, mega project, white elephant project…etc), i dont see Gerakan so high profile but instead choose to keep quite and stay away from it.

Gerakan is double face party and double standard when comes to those incident/cases, thats why rakyat hv seen gerakan true colour and is sick of it and hv voted out gerakan on last election.

5 william 13 Jun 2009, 4:45 PM

Xhu Chen,
i agree with you that it is time for gerakan youth to make reforms and the age limit of 45 years old is just going to make Gerakan Youth sounds like AH PEK CLUB.

But in politics, i think there will be a lot of selfish youth who want to hold on to position and will not agree to this.

And fully agree with penangite that Gerakan is near a useless party and also double face one! What really did Tan Beng Huat do that Gerakan did not do last time???

6 Atila 13 Jun 2009, 5:48 PM

I agree with Penangites.
Not just UMNO elites into corruption but all in the components, birds of the same feather flock together. So gerakan is still flocking together.

7 GenYong 14 Jun 2009, 3:35 PM

I agree with those who support penangites or Xhu Chen. Everything we talk must check before the real facts and talk it out. Don’t simply talk bad to others.

By the way, I believe the assemblymen Tan Beng Huat was a kind person. He won’t rasuah just like the UMNO assemblymen in the passed. He can challenge with others that he will resign if he checked got rasuah or anything.

Let’s think about it, how about UMNO assemblymen? After checked rasuah, nothing happen on them. Just freeze them in the party of UMNO for a few years, later come back again.

That’s really not fair, how to form a 1-Malaysia? Let’s think about it!

8 Mike 15 Jun 2009, 4:37 PM

PKR already make changes in their party.
I am suprise of PKR’s courage.
I hope gerakan can have the courage to change.
Gerakan had said going to change after GE 2008. But what change had been done?

I believe not all changes in PKR is good. But some like giving direct voting to members, lowering age of youth to 35 yrs old and 30% wanita representatives are GOOD REFORMS.

Maybe gerakan can try 20% representatives for woman and lower age of youth to 38 yrs old.
There must be sincerity in gerakan if they want to reform!

9 penangite 15 Jun 2009, 5:36 PM

Huan cheng guan is so arrogant in media yesterday.
He was supported by gerakan youth deputy national and penang youth chief Oh Tong Keong.

I think Teng Hock Nan got no choice but just to cool down now as Huan got more support in Penang.

10 Atila 17 Jun 2009, 2:56 AM

hcg if not careful will “terpelanting”.

arrogance is the root of evil to begin with. arrogance pun tarak guna, he still cannot leave gerakan afte all he ugut mau keluar, what political party wants him? tarak laku in pkr dap pas.

teng hock nan…he can wait, he has the patiece.

the ultimate agenda of hcg is to remove thn before next GE becoz UMNO Penang cannot work with thn. umno is dipping its fingers everywhere now.

11 Robert Chai 17 Jun 2009, 9:07 PM

What competence, accountability and transparent? 
We want leaders that can work for the benefit of the voters, carry out and implement policies that care for the people and dare to voice for the suppress. 

Our perception of Gerakan Youth is to organise more relevant activities to recruit more younger members.
Penang Gerakan is still alive and moving the right direction as their role to oppose. The main role is opposition.  Oppose what is not right.  That should be Gerakan policies.  Gerakan legacy is leave to the people to evaluate. They had make their choice with the political tsunami in the last GE.

Is it time to reflect what should be do to recover back? As the political struggle existed, let the delegates make their choice. We need to be issues oriented to gain back the support of the mass.

12 BadEnglish 17 Jun 2009, 10:59 PM

Some questions for Gerakan members and supporters to ponder :
a) Is the true opposition role that the Rakyat wanted you to play ? Just oppose for the sake of opposing ?
My take is that in the 60s and 70s, the answer is YES. But we are now in the 2010s and this meant that the society has progress and it is changed into a situation where the Rakyat want a more constructive government in waiting and not opposition. Government in waiting is able to present solution and provide the alternative choice to the Rakyat to convince them of their capabilities. Opposition role does not demonstrate this and we will end up like what we have today.

b) Have Gerakan ever stopped to ask the true question why did you lost the last round or you already have the answer. Well, if you already have the answer, I believed you will know what strategy to apply. The hardest part is to understand the root cause otherwise whatever strategy that you used will not yield results.

c) Have Gerakan gauge its chances of whether the Rakyat is willing to give them a chance again should the election being held 3 months from now ? Or will the Rakyat voted out both BN and PR but giving Penang and their 40 friends a chance to rule as TRUE Malaysians where they propel the new concept of a better Malaysia with a blue print plan on how to carry out the economy reform and also the society reform. Check with your Gerakan friend’s and you will realize the underlying feelings and reality.

d) Is your Co-Ordinator able to hold their ground against the current PR representative ?

e) I believed there are many more questions than answers for now but without the questions, your dreams of capturing Penang will only be a pipe dreams.

13 penangites 18 Jun 2009, 5:13 PM

Badenglish,

your question (d) really makes me wonder…....how come most of the coordinators of Gerakan are either of poor qualification or someone unknown to penang people?

14 Gerakan Spirit 18 Jun 2009, 5:43 PM

Firedog,
You are right of your point. but why not you think in this way, if you use the proper way of presentation/communication, you will get more audience?

Because of many politicians do not care the language they use, or rather to say that they do know what they are referring/talking, it make the politic talk such a low class dialogue all this while.

Cheers

15 gerakan man 19 Jun 2009, 3:37 PM

People don’t mind if you get some qualified people to be coordinator. Qualified means being professional, having a proper livelihood (income) and does not depend on party to make money, and having been serving the people n party. Can Gerakan Penang name me how many of the coordinator are of this quality?

16 gerakan man 19 Jun 2009, 3:41 PM

One more thing, the coordinator are given allocation fund for his area and also a salary (a few thousand),

All this money must be contributed back to the party including the salary.!!!!

17 BadEnglish 19 Jun 2009, 3:58 PM

Gerakan man,
Do you consider me qualified for the Co-Ordinator role ?

Anyway, please visit the CatWatch section to see my open letter to Pakatan Team on their recent comments about Penang.

18 Gerakan Spirit 19 Jun 2009, 4:59 PM

Gerakan really needs to bring the changes to the party, until now, we still do not see any obvious changes within the party.

19 penangites 19 Jun 2009, 5:24 PM

gerakan spirit,

at least u still can admit gerakan still no obvious changes…at least u still got cure…and gerakan still got little hope of survival.

20 "许子根" 20 Jun 2009, 12:39 PM

许子根:小学数理应以马來文为媒介语

This is what Our “Beloved” Presiden KTK said in SEMINAR Bahasa Kebangsaan Masyarakat Cina

““Saya akui kita sememangnya perlu menguasai lebih daripada satu bahasa, tetapi biarlah subjek Sains dan Matematik diajar dalam bahasa kebangsaan pada peringkat rendah bagi mengekalkan semangat 1Malaysia yang menjadi asas perpaduan,”

http://www.bharian.com.my/Curren ... /Article/index_html

ALL GERAKAN MEMBERs esp Commitee members, pls voice you opnion.

21 penangites 20 Jun 2009, 10:21 PM

许子根 only know to kow-tow(bow head) and lick UMNO leader boot and ass only…shame on him…

22 penang man 21 Jun 2009, 7:39 PM

Gerakan divisions in Seberang Prai will be holding meetings soon to discuss their next course of action following the three-year suspension slapped on party vice-president Huan Cheng Guan.

The party’s Kepala Batas division head Jeffrey Beh said the grassroots were upset over the suspension.

“Many have called me to express their anger. Some are thinking of joining other parties in Barisan Nasional and even the Opposition,” he said here Sunday.

Beh said the three-year suspension was akin to sacking Huan from the party.

“The grassroots are shocked that the party can impose this heavy punishment on a senior leader who was elected as vice-president,” he said.

Huan said he believed his sacking was orchestrated by party adviser Tun Dr Lim Keng Yaik.

“It is no secret that he wants his son Si Pin to become the next party president. They want to finish me off because I am a threat to Si Pin.

“I won the vice-president’s post from among eight contenders even though I was not on their ‘menu’.

“They kicked out Dr Goh Cheng Teik and he left the party quietly.

“In my case, even if I leave, I will continue to speak out from outside. After all, my supporters are still inside the party,” he said.

Huan said he was suspended without being given the opportunity to defend himself.

“They don’t do this in the MCA or Umno,” he said.

He said some Gerakan leaders were good at spinning stories about him.

“But when facing the Opposition, they become headless chickens.”

Huan said members were unhappy an outsider was appointed the co-ordinator of the Machang Bubok constituency.

“The man is from Bagan. Furthermore, he is a life member of another Barisan component party.

“Everyone in Penang knows this except some Gerakan leaders. They prefer to sweep this under the carpet,” he said.

Nibong Tebal MP Tan Tee Beng, who is the former Penang Gerakan Youth vice-chairman, said the party was out to kill Huan’s political career.

“They can suspend him for a year but why three years? This is to stop him from contesting in the next general election,” he said.

23 penang man 21 Jun 2009, 7:42 PM

http://www.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/6/21/nation/20090621182536&sec=nation

This is the link for the above article.

Only shows how leaders in Gerakan kill off good leaders so that some useless person can be their leader. Koh Tsu Koon already destroy gerakan last year…...just imagine what will Lim Keng Yaik son will do to Gerakan!!!
Please support Huan Cheng Guan!!!

24 penangites 21 Jun 2009, 8:42 PM

Dear all,

what i comments all the while about gerakan n their leaders becomes reality n truth.

This message specially dedicated to someone so call himself “gerakan spirit”. Now he can dream with his gerakan spirit.

25 wisely 21 Jun 2009, 9:18 PM

I think we all want what the best for our party. So, the best is to calm down. Be rational rather than emotional. I think the purpose of punishment is so that he would learn a lessen and NOT to finish him off. Tun’s personal history of how he raise to power speaks a lot. If he is so narrow minded probably our party may have long gone. If he will to use this tactics for his son to raise to the top, then i think gerakan has no future( now i don’t know what’s what
I am just a small potato. I don’t know anyone and no one know me but i just want to see and analyse the situation rationally) But i heard Tun spoke and the our president spoke in Ipoh last year.

Sincerely speaking, I believe because my father who join Gerakan even before Tun did affirm his words. To me, Tun is too broad to be this narrow and to resort to do this for his son. Again i say, i just try to analyse the situation rationally. I do hope we put party interest first. Just appeal, things have not reach an end of no return. To those who are close to our VP, please advise him positively.

Just to share a story with u. I almost quit Gerakan to join opposition before 308. The sentiment was and is high. I was not at all boarder about politic though i am a member since 2001 due to my dad. He talk a lot of politic to me but i was never interested to be involve. That night i remember all the DAP big gun was in Sitiawan but my inner conscience stop me from attending. I know 4-5 PR MP or ADUN personally(some of them were not yet MP or ADUN then). To be frank i knew no one in our party then. Is not easy for me then to decide to stick to our party(of couse i am nobody). But i got my calling affirmed after hearing Tun testimony follow by Tan Sri Koh’s.

After 308, Tan Sri was accused of land scandal in Penang. But the debate really open my eyes to see the real motive behind the accusation and who LGE really is. I think all of us would agree with me even those who are not with us would sense the real reason behind the accusation. I was really impressed with our record in Penang all these years, 99.9%.

Look at their CAT, how many questions we post on this website are answered? And look at their former DPM1.
To me, they are not ‘angels’ also. To me i just look at the result, look at the facts. Let them rule for 5 years. Penang People will know and can judge for themselves who are better!

26 wisely 21 Jun 2009, 9:51 PM

Few days ago i was shock to read Tony Pua’s Press statement about the allegation made by one of PR councillor about the allocation made between them 30% 40% 30% follow by RPK open gun at PR saying that it took PR 1 yr to develop what took BN 50 yrs to develop and threaten to close down the comment section if all the comments were just aim at BN and none at PR.

I think irrespective of PR or BN, human are still human. BN politians are human and so are PR politicians. I had also listen to Aminah’s CD recording. Ya, its good to know the truth.

I believe power can corrupt people fast once people possess it. I remember a story in the Bible about Moses’s rod that split the red sea. He was asked by God to hold the snake by its tail and it became a rod. The rod signified power. If he were to hold the snake by the head he would be bitten by the snake. All politicians need to learn how to hold the snake by the tail as to not abuse the power confer to them by the rakyat. But how many politician know how to handle power and not be bitten?

Its easy to criticise but to walk the talk, not many can because we have to admit it is not easy. I think the best way is still to hold to the right principle. Be a principle centered leader! I think Stephen Covey had it right.

27 BadEnglish 22 Jun 2009, 7:55 AM

My interpretation from what was left by Penang Man - Huan will be or going to go for the President’s post or does he see himself as a President designate until this recent episode ?

Before we even decide to thread that path, we need to review some of the facts and data.
a) Will Gerakan flourish or going all the way down under Huan’s leadership ?
b) What is Huan’s future vision for Gerakan and how is he going to turn their fortune around ? (He is a VP that is voted in as what he claims. So, what are the changes that he has brought about to win back Penang ?)
c) Has he demonstrate maturity in handling tough issue ? (UMNO, ISA and etc other than releasing press statement?)
d) A loyal party man (this is what he claims and not me making up) will not hold their own party at ransom. Is he still a true party man or opportunist ?

The question goes on and on…

28 Mr Penang 22 Jun 2009, 1:21 PM

Huan says that Gerakan leader is cold blooded. Does anyone belief that Lim Keng Yaik is behind all this???


“They are cold-blooded and will kill you politically without hesitation and without having any remorse if you were to challenge and criticise them,” said Huan, adding that he believed his suspension was a conspiracy orchestrated by the party’s former president Tun Dr Lim Keng Yaik.

Dr Lim, he said, wanted his son, Si Pin, who is now the party’s national Youth chief, to be the eventual president.

“I believe Tan Sri Dr Koh Tsu Koon will also be on the list as the next victim because of Penang Gerakan’s disastrous performance in last year’s general election.”

http://www.nst.com.my/Current_News/NST/Monday/National/2588514/Article/index_html

29 penangites 23 Jun 2009, 11:56 AM

Now gerakan own leader is saying what i comments about gerakan and its leader since the beginning…. below is the statement from him obtain from press.

Donno how those person like “gerakan spirit” think when they saw this from their own party leader. Those person is useless n only know how to personal attack. They only humiliating their own party they work for.

Quote Malaysiakini:

“The suspension will effectively bar me from contesting any party posts in 2011, as well as any contest for member of Parliament and state assemblyman.
“I suspect that some old men in the party are trying their best to kill younger leaders with grass-root support, to clear the path for their princes and princesses to take over the party,”

story in Sin Chew Daily today:

  被凍結黨籍3年的民政黨副主席范清淵對該黨主席丹斯里許子根的軟弱及講話不算話的作風感到非常失望。
  他透露6月18日(週四)在國會時,許子根還叫他多寫一次道歉信,並承諾最多僅會凍結其黨籍6個月。
  “然而基於原則問題,我拒絕作出第二次道歉,也認為沒有必要,結果卻被凍結3年黨籍。”

  “尤其他(許子根)對外像無膽母雞,對內就很勇敢嚴厲的作風,更是讓人不敢恭維。當巫青團高舉海報羞辱他及再納阿比丁當眾撕毀其照片時,許子根哪敢哼一聲?”

  范清淵是今日(週日,6月21日)早上親自致電《星洲日報》表達其不滿時強調,民政黨對他作出的指責皆是莫須有的罪名,而且也完全沒有讓他解釋的機會就立刻判刑,相信這僅是民政黨才有的作風。
  他也不知為何黨高層如何怕見到他,為何沒有膽量召見他及讓他能夠當面作出解釋。

Malaysiakini Chinese edition:
  虽然遭到民政党副主席范清渊炮轰软弱及讲话不算话,但是该党主席许子根今日却拒绝做出回应,甚至在记者提及“范清渊”的名字时,便立即打断记者的询问, 说:“我不想回应范清渊的课题”。

30 BadEnglish 23 Jun 2009, 12:35 PM

I am amaze that PKR has even rejected Huan’s membership before he can apply. PKR really doesn’t even appreciate his grassroot support or rather PKR thinks that he doesn’t have them. Only PKR can answer.

In all political turmoil, the leaders needs to take a hard decision for the future sake of the party. Once a decision is being made and also as long as it is being made on a fair ground basis and along the Party’s constitution, the rest will be history.

There are 2 sides impact -
a) The person leaves and the whole party is very weakened but it allows the renewal process to takes place as leaders leave, it creates a vaccuum and new leaders will emerge. It maybe a slow renewal process but it will definitely happen. If it turns out the renewal process brought about a charismatic leader, then the party will be better than it is today. If it is just a so-so leader, then the Party will be what it is today. Can no longer be any worst, I believed.

b) If the person who leaves are the baggage to their Party, more new members will join and the Party will be strengthened in a short time. Well, I am making the assumption that the new more members are all sincere and contributing members and this may be a small sacrifice but a big gain.

At the end of the day, the leaders will know best as their own members have voted them in. This is where you get what you have voted for. All of its members will need to be accountable.

31 OOI 26 Jun 2009, 11:07 AM

Ahyo ...Siasuilah PR .  Ppl votes you with a new hope. But since 308 so many Adun involve in scandal case… only one year so many cases liao.

I still remember, the morning that BktJawi Adun YB Tan being suspected of expense scandal.

That night, Lim remains us about the Land Scam in press.

CM Lim, I really solute you ..shit is on your face and you are still able to point at others.
Wasted my 308 vote!  Really disappointed

32 dog watch 28 Jun 2009, 9:59 PM

Ask your state chairman how many members joined gerakan after 308????

33 penangites 29 Jun 2009, 1:06 PM

one thing for sure, those were left Gerakan is much more than joining ... including some senior and respectful leader as well.

those still not left just waiting for their days to come, they still think miracle can happen and die die holding gerakan leg, bcos people of penang already see their true face for selling off penang and its peoples interest to their master UMNO during their ruling.

34 LangChiaPek 30 Jun 2009, 6:56 PM

so what is the outcome to this case ?

if Mr Tan Beng Huat is clear of any charges why those who point fingers at him never say sorry to him ?

35 penangites 1 Jul 2009, 12:53 AM

langchiapek,

i dont think so…they just keep quiet and pretend nothing happen and try to wait for other things that   might happen from Penang PR government so that they hv issue to bring out and make cheap publication for their own personal and party image…that so CAT watch…

furthermore, the Tan Beng Huat case is not bring up by Gerakan themself but is DAP own branch leader expose it. This is more better than gerakan that not even dare to disclose their own scandal…

Gerakan not even doing a proper opposition job, shame lah…

36 penangites 29 Jul 2009, 2:20 PM

槟爪夷州议员洗脱拨款缩水指控
限指控者及新海峡报三天内道歉

曾被指控“拨款缩水”而掀起槟州政坛大波的槟州行动党爪夷州议员陈明发,已接获反贪委员会来函证实其清白,其案件已在没有做出指控之下完结。

陈明发是日前接获反贪会志期7月23日的来函,证实其案件已经关档。

因此,他将在近期内致函槟州首长林冠英,撤回未在指控爆发时,所签署的一封未志明日期辞职信。

此外,他限定指控他的行动党高渊区部主席郑福荣和刊登相关新闻的《新海峡时报》在三天内,无条件通过媒体公开道歉,否则将采取法律行动起诉。

37 penangites 1 Aug 2009, 3:14 PM

Tan Beng Huat, A Fine Example to Follow
On July 15, Nibong Tebal DAP division chief Teh Hock Yong lodged four reports with the MACC against Tan for alleged abuse of power, misappropriation of allocation and using the state logo on a letter to raise RM5,000 for a Chinese temple.

Tan, the Jawi assemblyman, did not only cooperate with the anti-corruption investigators but he also submitted an undated resignation letter to the Penang chief minister to be executed if he was found guilty.

He has been cleared of abuse of power allegations as investigations by the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) found that there was no evidence to implicate him.

Tan said he had received a letter from Penang MACC director Latifah Mad Yatim, dated July 23, stating that the case had been closed.

All elected representatives currently being investigated by the MACC should do the same thing. Will Khir Toyo lead the way for BN?
Posted by Khoo Kay Peng at 4:12 PM 31 comments

Post Comment

Commenting is not available in this section entry.